Why I unlinked my fan Page and Twitter account

by Peter Fletcher on November 17, 2009

I recently linked my Facebook fan Page to my Twitter account. The thinking behind the move was simple. First the audiences for both my Page and Twitter accounts are similar making the content of the Page post and tweet relevant in both cases. Second, when I update my Page Facebook creates s tweet giving me one less thing to do. Sounds simple enough, but it’s not.

I imagined that any link contained within the Page post would be sent (probably in shortened form) in the tweet.  Instead Facebook send Twitter a link to the post on the Facebook Page (here’s an example), and not the link posted to the Page.

What this means is that users are taken to a page on Facebook  that contains the original post. From there they must then click through to the article. It’s a long way around.

Facebook may be trying to help Page owners by driving traffic back to the Page post and therefore the Page. I’d like to think that’s the case. A more cynical view is that Facebook is attempting to grab a few extra ad-carrying page impressions. Maybe that’s going too far.  Whatever their reasons it’s a clumsy arrangement that doesn’t work well for the end user.

As of yesterday I’ve unlinked my Facebook Page and Twitter account until they get it sorted out.

  • Share/Bookmark

Related Posts:

  • ronpadua
    Hmmm. Is Peter onto something more sinister here....watch this space as the up and coming doyen of online media strategy struts his stuff.
  • Tried Twitter to Facebook and Facebook to Twitter on TRET Facebook page also and found both unsatisfactory so unlinked about a month ago. Found out through trial and error just like you did. You can use a product called Involver on Facebook to create a Twitter tab on the business home page and you can also have PDF, You Tube etc tabs. You get 2 tabs for free and more to "go Pro". PDF one useful for e-books and whitepapers for fans. Oh, BTW I don't work for them just sharing.
  • Thanks for the tips Lara. I checked out, and became a fan of, TRET on Facebook. Those tabs seem to work nicely.
  • It's all a bit mind-boggling to me still at the moment, so simpler is certainly better in my opinion.
  • Yes, simple is good Esther. Mix that with a good dose of patience and you're on the right track.
  • We did the same thing with our feed. As an alternative, we recently added our Twitter feed to its own tab. Still trying to figure out if this is ideal or not.
  • I don't think you are being cynical Peter. With the possibility of retweets, this type of arrangement has the potential to generate considerable amounts of traffic back towards the Facebook fan page.
  • chrissylvester
    Clumsy indeed - exactly why I too unlinked my accounts
blog comments powered by Disqus